Nothing is more disappointing than the collapse of the Advisor Perspectives editorial package—except maybe how Financial Planning magazine devolved into a broker-ish publication when it went to a subscription model. It represents a loss to the advisor community, but of course that’s out of our control.
I enjoyed the interview with Emily Biehler, who charges non-AUM fees and offers financial planning services that are revolve around client short-term and long-term goals—and the completion of tasks related to those goals. The highlights of Financial Planning magazine’s AI conference suggest (to me) that the benefits and feature set of artificial intelligence are still a bit nebulous, even to tech insiders. And Michael Kitces and Carl Richards offer some back-and-forth insights on delegation, with the takeaway that advisors should hire staff that are wired differently than they are to take on tasks that they (the advisors) want to delegate.
Advisor Perspectives columns:
“Advisors Should Adapt to Evolving Client Expectations”
by Matt Reiner
Advisor Perspectives, November 5, 2024
https://www.advisorperspectives.com/articles/2024/11/05/advisors-adapt-evolving-client-expectations
Relevance: high
The article recommends that advisors practice ‘open communication’ with clients, which allows for asking questions and exchanging ideas. We are told that ‘today’s investors are looking for more than just traditional portfolio management,’ and then the article lists various financial planning advice topics. Hybrid investors who want to manage their own assets should be met with advisor technology that allows them to log in and view their account and portfolio at any time, and receive market updates and personal notifications. You should consider relaxing your AUM minimums or do away with them altogether.
“What Advisors Need from Tech in 2025”
by Adrian Johnstone
Advisor Perspectives, November 6, 2024
https://www.advisorperspectives.com/articles/2024/11/06/what-advisors-need-tech-2025
Relevance: high
This might be the first article I’ve seen to say what is true about tech adoption: it is typically led, in advisory firms, by the operations teams. Most tools, so far, promise automation and workflow improvements. The article says that advisors tend to be less focused on the office tech, but younger advisors are more savvy and impatient about tech than founders who may be preparing for their own exit. Advisors need to see that tech—particularly the CRM—is integral to building better client relationships. And more efficient, deeper client relationship-building can be the key to firm growth.
“Understanding Profits Interests and How They Can Help RIAs Retain Top Talent”
by Richard Chen
Advisor Perspectives, November 11, 2024
https://www.advisorperspectives.com/articles/2024/11/11/understanding-profits-interests-how-can-help-rias-retain-talent
Relevance: high
If you want to attract and retain talent with an attractive compensation package, but don’t want to give away equity freely, profits interests provide a flexible alternative. You can grant a key staff person a percentage of the future profits of the business, or in the proceeds from the eventual sale of the RIA. The grantee only benefits if the company grows or is sold at a profit, which creates an incentive to help drive future success.
The article says that this allows the owner to retain voting shares, and the employees don’t have to purchase their interest. The profits interests can be subject to vesting, rewarding employees for their continued service to the firm. They can vest over specified time periods or (the flexibility thing again) upon achieving specific performance milestones. The author says that profits interests can become a ‘trial run’ for equity ownership.
Nerd’s Eye View articles:
“Delivering Financial Planning Profitably to Every Client with a Focus on Accountability over ‘Just’ Meetings, with Emily Biehler”
by Michael Kitces (interviewer)
Nerd’s Eye View November 5, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/emily-biehler-trailwise-financial-partners-plan-process-accountability-meeting-profitability/
Relevance: high
Biehler is the co-founder of TrailWise Financial Partners in Golden, CO, with $80 million in AUM for 200 client households. Here, she says she changed her service model because so many clients were not taking action on her advice. Clients would leave the office excited about making progress, and then things would come up and they would get too distracted with their busy lives to follow through.
She started out creating detailed 12 page plan summaries for clients, but was disconcerted that they weren’t reading them. Then she added a Find Your Path workbook, which helped clients articulate and define their goals and values—values around things like whether they’re comfortable taking on debt to make purchases, goals around things like paying for children’s college. There’s a behavioral component that asks about the clients’ relationship with money and whether clients need a lot or a little accountability from their advisor.
The service is called a Client Experience Journey, with hiking imagery. Fees start at a flat $3,000 for the first year, but it can go up as Biehler evaluates the scope of the engagement. The initial fee covers eight subjects, and clients can add to it: work benefits, business ownership, rental properties. Will she be meeting with the CPA and attorney and business manager throughout the year? The most complicated clients pay $10,000 a year, and the fee level can change, with changes in complexity, from year to year. Clients are not required to have the firm manage the investable assets.
The plan has targets like: my cash flow or my emergency fund should be at this level by the end of 12 months. There are some 90-day goals, and Biehler will send a pre-recorded video to see if the client is achieving those goals, and clients can respond via email whether they’re still on track. At the start of the next year of the engagement, Biehler will celebrate the achievement of goals, which she says re-engages her clients. She sends out an customized Plan Update email after each year, which includes a review of completed and upcoming goals.
What’s different is that a lot of these personal communications are via a pre-recorded video that clients can then respond back from via email. She says that she’ll record several videos at once for different clients, basically updating their plan and asking about their new goals. The goal is more efficiency than a bunch of in-person meetings that tend to stray into a lot of personal conversation.
“Values, Purpose, Action: A 3-Part Approach to Establish a ‘Statement of Financial Purpose’ and Unlock Deeper, More Meaningful Planning Conversations with Clients”
by Jeremy Walter and Andy Baxley
Nerd’s Eye View November 6, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/statement-of-financial-purpose-goals-values-based-meaninfgul-action-planning-reflective-quetsions-communication-discovery/
Relevance: high
Walter is founder of Fident Financial in Lancaster, PA and Baxley founded Two Trails Financial Planning, a remote planning office. They say that a key objective of a planning engagement is to help clients connect their money withy their values, and aligning financial advice with those values.
The article offers a rough framework for making this happen. It starts with values, where you say up-front that you do your best work for clients when you have achieved an understanding of what and who is most important to them. If you get permission to move forward, there are sample questions to ask:
1) Describe your perfect day in vivid detail. Where are you? What are you doing? Who are you with?
2) How do you define success in this chapter of your life?
3) When it comes to your personal and financial life, what do you need to feel confident and secure?
4) Imagine you’re in the final hours of a rich and fulfilling life. From that vantage point, how would you describe a life well-lived?
The article offers some followup questions like: What was it like, thinking through your answer to this question? Did anything surprising or unexpected come up as you answered this question? Why is that important to you? etc.
The article includes a ‘client values checklist’ with 57 values, among them ‘adventure,’ ‘connection,’ ‘discipline,’ ‘fun,’ ‘honesty,’ ‘meaningful work,’ ‘safety,’ and ‘wisdom.’ Clients are encouraged to narrow this list to just three to five personal values, and to prioritize them.
Next is purpose. Clients are introduced to the concept of a Statement of Financial Purpose, which is described as the ‘why’ behind your wealth. The article includes a sample statement, and prompt statements for clients to complete, such as ‘Money’s purpose in my life is…’, ‘Financial success means to me…’, and ‘True wealth is…’ Clients write a first draft, and then asked ‘How are you feeling about your first draft overall?’ and ‘Do you have any ideas for how we might improve your statement to make it more motivating or clarifying?’
Finally there’s action. Once you’ve identified what truly matters to the client, the question is: what will the client do to honor their values and live up to their Statement of Financial Purpose? Clients articulate short-term and long-term goals to be achieved, and the reader is prompted to follow up with: ‘What about that goal fees important to you?’ and “What would you be most likely to regret not doing?’ The article says that specificity is the key here; vague objectives like ‘travel more’ lack the clarity needed for effective planning.
On an ongoing basis, advisors hold clients accountable to their goals and values with regular check-ins to track progress and adjust strategies as needed.
“How Outsourcing Marketing Can Unlock Growth Potential for Advisory Firms: Key Steps for Choosing the Right Provider”
by Lauren Hong and Tiffany Silverberg
Nerd’s Eye View November 11, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/outsourced-marketing-provider-strategy-firm-growth-how-to-choose-contractor-agency-partner/
Relevance: high
The authors are President and Director of Marketing Strategy for Out & About Communications, which help advisory firms market themselves. The article says that fewer than 30% of RIA firms with more than $100 million AUM have a defined marketing strategy, and 85% of advisors report that they don’t have the time to focus on marketing.
The idea here is that an outsource marketing provider is likely to have more expertise in the modern nuances of digital marketing than the in-house staff. There’s a long list of things that can be outsourced: brand positioning and messaging, graphic design and copywriting, social media management, SEO and website development, email marketing, paid advertising, media outreach, video production and editing, webinar management, tracking marketing analytics and event planning.
The needed services will vary with firm size. Smaller firms with 5 or fewer employees need to build a brand and social media presence. Firms with 10-30 employees need to focus on creating consistent messaging related to the brand, a data-driven marketing approach and a process for converting leads. Larger firms may need to develop a formalized brand book, staff marketing training, ways to leverage centers of influence and a brand personality that the team understands.
The article says that some outsource providers offer support on short-term tasks, some are off-the-shelf solutions, some are free-lancers who specialize in a particular area (copywriting or design), some are specialty providers in a specialized service like direct mail or website development, some are full-suite marketing agencies that offer comprehensive marketing support, and some are consultants or fractional chief marketing officers who will manage the firm’s marketing needs and give guidance on branding, messaging, service model, fee structure and other issues. (A flowchart helps guide the reader to which is the best option.
We are given questions to ask your team before hiring a marketing provider. What are we looking for in an ideal partnership? What skill set gaps do we have? What’s our budget and anticipated return on investment? What’s our time-line? Who will lead this initiative? When vetting an outsource marketing provider, propose a trial period to demonstrate value, and explore how the partnership relates to firm goals. Find that provider through referrals from colleagues or from industry events. Leverage free consultations and conduct an online search. When you talk with the providers before hiring, show them examples of previous successful work, and provide clear guidelines.
During the relationship, you should measure progress and results, which means you need to define your unique success metrics. Goals can be refined as objectives are achieved. The article says that it is important to set realistic expectations for when the firm expects to see measurable results, which basically means be patient. If the partnership is producing stagnant or declining results, you should explore other options, and you may outgrow your current provider as your scale increases. Beware of poor communication or a mismatch in culture, values or working style.
“Getting Clients Comfortable with Market Risk Using a More (Options-Based) Measured Risk Approach, with Larry Kriesmer”
by Michael Kitces (interviewer)
Nerd’s Eye View November 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/larry-kriesmer-measured-risk-portfolios-equity-market-risk-options/
Relevance: high
Kriesmer is Chairman of Measured Risk Portfolios, an RIA in San Diego that oversees $350 million in AUM. He describes his investment process as buying a zero coupon bond that will appreciate, over five years to some limited loss; he uses the example of putting $820,000 of a million dollar portfolio into the bond at a 5% rate, so the client would get back $850,000 when the bond matures, and that creates a maximum downside risk of 15% on the entire portfolio. The other $180,000 is invested in an option contract that is designed to move up much faster than the market moves up—leveraged to gain eight to 12 times the rate of the market on that smaller part of the portfolio. There is constant buying of option contracts as clients deposit more money in their retirement accounts, and the firm will harvest the gains if and when the option starts to outperform its target. If the options become worthless, the downside risk is capped at 15% over some time period. The actual floor is client-specific, depending on clients’ risk tolerance.
“2024 Election: Evaluating the Impact of a (Likely) Republican Trifecta on the TCJA Sunset and Tax Planning”
by Ben Henry-Moreland
Nerd’s Eye View November 13, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/2024-election-republican-trifecta-trump-2025-tcja-sunset-tax-planning-tax-cut-and-jobs-act-salt-congress/
Relevance: high
The last time Republicans won the Presidency, the House and the Senate, the result was the 2017 Tax Cuts & Jobs Act, a sprawling package of tax cuts and additional complexity. It famously came with an expiration date within 10 years of its passage, ending on December 31, 2025, but this article suggests that the new regime will extend it, with some modifications.
Such as? No detailed plan was offered by the Republicans, but on the campaign trail, Candidate Trump promised to make the interest on auto loans tax-deductible. The article says that the Section 199A deduction for owners of pass-through businesses will be retained or possibly increased, and Candidate Trump floated the idea of reducing corporate tax rates from 21% to 15% while restoring the immediate expensing for R&D costs.
The estate tax and generation-skipping tax exemptions exploded under TCJA, and the Republican party has pushed to eliminate estate taxes altogether. The article says there is no longer an immediate need to gift assets before the TCJA sunset.
Repealing the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, which created or expanded tax credits for solar panels, home energy efficiency upgrades and electric vehicles would be a first priority for the new Administration, so making taxpayers might want to take advantage of these credits sooner rather than later.
“What’s Holding You Back from Delegating What You Need to Let Go Of?”
by Michael Kitces and Carl Richards
Nerd’s Eye View November 14, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/151-michael-kitces-carl-richards-podcast-delegation-automation-challenges-practice-management-team-tasks/
Relevance: high
Richards starts off by advocating a ‘to don’t do’ file, a list of things that the leadership team members should ideally delegate. And then they delegate them. Simple, right?
Actually, he says, there are a lot of feelings around giving up tasks that you’re accustomed to doing. One is the idea that the remote worker or staffer can’t do it as well as you can. You can do it faster than teaching someone else to do it. And Kitces says that if you make of list of things that you feel like are sucking your energy, is it fair to give this toxic list of tasks to someone on staff? Is it fair to say, hey, let’s hire someone and make them do all the things that I hate to do. The idea made him feel guilty.
Eventually, he realized that not everyone is wired like he is, and that terrible task list was actually attractive to people with a different mindset. And the staff people want to take on extra responsibilities; otherwise they don’t feel like they’re fully contributing.
There’s a back-and-forth about how some staff members like to finish tasks they’re assigned, but they aren’t good at thinking about what should be done, or the bigger picture. Richards talks about an advisor who puts more detail into a job description: “Are you the kind of person who just loves having a checklist in front of them and then check off the tasks? He says that many big picture people find it hard to understand how others can think that way, who love the details and organizing files and going into the Airtable databases and catalog everything.
But… No one else can do these tasks as well as you can, right? Kitces says that if somebody enjoys the task that you dislike, they’ll probably do a better job of it. He outlines his delegation process, which is turn on screen share and narrate the task as he’s doing it. Then, when you train somebody in the process, don’t be surprised if they do it differently from how you defined the task. If, in other words, they find ways to do it more efficiently and better.
Toward the end, Kitces notes that many firm founders make the mistake of trying to hire people just like them, who are 10 or 15 years younger. But he points out that the founder is a person who doesn’t want to work for someone else, who doesn’t like to do the same things the founder doesn’t like to do. Better to hire somebody with opposite tendencies, who will enjoy doing the things the founder hates to do.
“Highlights from the Advise AI Conference 2024”
by Craig Iskowitz
Nerd’s Eye View November 18, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/advise-ai-conference-summary-adviseai-artificial-intelligence-financial-advice-craig-iskowitz/
Relevance: high
The author, the CEO and founder of the Ezra Group tech consulting firm, attended Financial Planning magazine’s Advise AI conference in Las Vegas, which focused, we are told, on ‘the transformational impact of artificial intelligence on financial advice.” Later, he calls it ‘a new form of human-machine partnership,’ and quotes from speakers to the effect that AI is augmenting human capabilities.
Iskowitz offers highlights and key insights from different presentations, but you might find yourself questioning the value of the conference when you read them. Michael Kitces warns tech companies not to lead with AI in their marketing, but instead focus on use cases. (None are mentioned.) A speaker with CogniCor Technologies said that AI can help advisors achieve personalization, which, he said, means ‘having knowledge of the opportunities and risks for each client and delivering this in a proactive manner in the right context.’ (No example is given here about how any technology will help advisors do this.)
An executive at InvestCloud says that AI requires a unified data warehouse to ‘work its magic’ across multiple systems and data sources. There’s a list with no particulars offered (or, indeed, companies that are offering anything on the list): predictive alerting, advisory intelligence, business intelligence, guiding advisors through client life events and generating personalized investment proposals.
But, we are told, AI is great for operational efficiency. An advisor noted that his firm deployed new account-opening processes using technology that created personalized experiences for clients. (How?) An executive from Cambridge Investment Research reported that advisors using AI-enhanced meeting tools Jump and Socks saved thousands of hours of time. These and other products offer transcription capabilities, surfacing action items from the conversations and highlighting changes in client circumstances. A program called Zeplyn is using AI to allow advisory firms to create workflow automation and form filling functionality.
An attorney from MarketCounsel told the audience that advisory firms need to develop AI( use policies, and a representative of Surge Ventures said AI has the potential to handle regulatory events—but the article doesn’t say how that would work. Another tech executive ‘stressed the importance of high-quality data for effective AI models.’ (No kidding!)
A panel discussion featured an executive at Salesforce, an advisor, and a senior executive at JP Morgan. They recommended ‘taking a strategic approach to AI implementation,’ and choose a high-impact use case involving client onboarding, summarizing client interactions, generating sales scripts, client meeting prep and summaries, enriching lead data to improve sales outcomes, summarizing research documents, and mining internal policies and procedures.
In the future, a presenter told the audience, AI could democratize access to sophisticated investment strategies. Another said that in the future, AI solutions will be tailored to the specific needs and requirements of the industry.
At the end, Andrew Altfest of FP Alpha said that AI can enhance activities like client communication, advice and new client onboarding. Brad DeLoatche of Snappy Kraken said that AI ‘can help advisors truly understand their clients’ needs and preferences. Brian Wallheimer, editor-in-chief of Financial Planning magazine said that AI can help advisors “spend time on the right things’ which he defined as building relationships with clients. Susan Theder at FMG said that advisors can leverage AI to write content, and made some prompt engineering suggestions: upload your own writing and then ask AI to mimic your ‘voice,’ and articulate the goal and tone of what you’re asking it to write.
There’s no doubt these individuals could have (and might have) provided a lot of useful specifics, but from this writeup, it sounds like, at this stage of ‘the AI revolution,’ even the experts are mostly offering a lot of generalities.
“3X’ing the Business with No More Than 50 Great Clients by Hyperfocusinog on Who You Can Add the Most Value for, with Anjali Jariwala”
by Michael Kitces (interviewer)
Nerd’s Eye View November 19, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/anjali-jariwala-fit-advisors-marketing-growth-revenue-triple-niche-physicians/
Relevance: high
Jariwala is founder of FIT Advisors in Torrance, CA, a CPA with $65 million in assets for 45 client households, all of them physician households with complex tax needs or small business owners. (Her husband is a physician.) She started a 45-60 minute podcast and writes a blog, so her marketing is a new piece of content coming out every week. She focused on topics that her ideal top ten clients were most interested in. Apparently physicians like real estate investing, so she created episodes in how to get into real estate investing and what to look for. She started sending the messages out to current clients, and attracted a small core viewership of 1,000 download per episode—who are right in her target market. She also reached out to physicians who have their own podcasts, and asked if she could be a guest speaker, and if they would come on her podcast.
The article says that the cost of hiring a ghost writer and video editing team costs $2,500 a month—10% of her top-line revenue. The niche client typically has between $500,000 to $2 million in investible assets, and pays an $18,000 minimum annual fee—with a $21,000 minimum for practice owners. She helps the physicians structure their contracts with medical groups and negotiate compensation. As a CPA, she can review tax returns and do tax planning, and looks at all the real estate investments.
“Seeking Best Execution: Understanding the SEC’s Expectations for Advisors to Deliver Best Outcomes for Clients”
by Chris Stanley
Nerd’s Eye View November 20, 2024
https://www.kitces.com/blog/sec-division-enforcement-investment-adviser-regulation-fiduciary-best-execution-trading-requirement/
Relevance: high
I very nearly didn’t include this article in these reviews (I usually just assume the Kitces articles are relevant), because the article doesn’t do anything close to what the title suggests. Instead, it reiterates a lot of somewhat obscure hinting from the SEC about what constitutes best execution, without giving any clear guidance on how that evaluation can be performed. That’s not the author’s fault, but instead of all these words and quotes, the author could have said that best execution means evaluating the totality of services that the custodial BD offers, not just speed or price or accuracy. (The article even includes research as something to consider, which this writer thinks is irrelevant to execution since it can be purchased elsewhere; it’s more of a soft dollar arrangement.)
The article notes that an SEC ‘risk alert’ from 2018 notes that the examiners found that advisors didn’t perform best-execution reviews. So you need something in the files that says you evaluated your current custodian based on a bunch of factors when you really don’t have a lot of data on the ins and outs of the alternative custodial technology, speed of execution, accuracy or even whether this or that custodian nickel and dimes customers. Got it.
